Methodology

ESG scoring methodology: how Than App scores a report.

Fixed, published rules decide every point, so the same report always gets the same score and anyone can check a result against the source. The score measures the quality of what a report discloses, not a company's real-world performance.

1. Read and detect

The report is split into sentences with their PDF page. Running headers, footers and contents pages are removed. Each statement is matched to one of 15 topics: GHG emissions, energy, water, waste and biodiversity (Environmental); workforce, health and safety, diversity, human rights and community (Social); board, ethics and anti-corruption, data privacy, risk transparency and executive pay (Governance).

2. Score each topic from 0 to 100

PartPointsWhat earns them
Coverage20Statements on the topic, up to 4
Figures20Share of those statements with a real figure
Depth10Distinct figures reported (years are not counted), up to 4
Dated target15A target with a date, such as "by 2030"
Baseline or trend15A comparison with a base year or an earlier year
Assurance10Independent assurance of the topic; 5 if only a report-wide assurance statement covers it
Required disclosures10Share of the Malaysian and international requirements for the topic that the report meets

Topic scores roll up into Environmental (40%), Social (30%) and Governance (30%), or the weights of one of 8 sector profiles. The overall score gives a rating from A (85 and above) to E (below 40) and a maturity level from Yet to Start to Advanced. Headings and index rows count as coverage only, and a target such as "30% by 2030" is never read as an actual result.

3. Check compliance

65 requirements from Bursa Malaysia's Listing Requirements, the MACC Act s17A guidelines, MCCG 2021, the PDPA, NSRF / IFRS S2, the GHG Protocol and GRI. Each is found or not, with the sentence and page; a figure must sit next to the indicator it measures. See compliance coverage.

4. Test for greenwashing risk

Five fixed tests add up to a risk score from 0 to 100: three or more vague claims without a figure (up to 30), environmental targets without a baseline (15), a net-zero claim without Scope 1 and 2 data (25; 10 if Scope 3 business travel and commuting are missing), no third-party assurance (15) and fewer than 40% of environmental statements quantified (15).

5. Map the implementation roadmap

Seven stages, following ESG Is Your Business: A Guide to Integrating and Reporting ESG (AMCHAM T&T, United Nations and EY, 2022): foundations, leadership and governance, expectations and materiality, risk management, strategy and policy, KPIs and targets, and reporting and assurance. Each stage shows its parts, a checklist with sources and the points to the next level.

6. Human review

Every result is an AI draft until your ESG Owner reviews it and a different Approver signs off. See governance and sign-off.

Limits of our ESG scoring methodology, stated openly

  • Rules match wording, so an unusually worded disclosure can be missed; your ESG Owner reviews every topic.
  • Figures inside images or scanned pages cannot be read; they are left blank, never guessed.
  • The check reads the report you upload; requirements met in other documents need to be noted by your team.
  • English reports only for now.

Method version v13.9. Every rule change gets a new version and a changelog entry.